Sunday, February 18, 2018

Alibaba's BOHICA "Acquisition" of 33% of Ant Financial....

As promised in my last post, I took some time to go through Alibaba's previously announced Ant Financial equity transaction.  (i.e. Alibaba's newly formed Subsidiary ends up with a 33% ownership interest in Ant Financial in exchange for some Intellectual Property and the elimination of the 37.5% profit sharing agreement.)

So let's get to it!

The Actual Deal Headline from the Alibaba PR Department Press Release reads as follows:

Alibaba Group Agrees to 33% Equity Stake in Ant Financial

I'll bet Jack had a tough time negotiating with himself, managing all of the legal and accounting talent, hell bent to protect his interests on both sides of the transaction.  Those long, grueling, stressful sessions in the board room, watching Jack manage cutthroat accountants and lawyers, who without his guidance, would have surely come to blows, must have been inspiring.  I heard Jack drives a hard bargain, but they finally got this done.  I hope he wasn't too hard on himself.

A couple of the key statements in the press release are as follows:
  • The parties have agreed to certain amendments to their 2014 transaction agreements to facilitate the transaction.
  • There will be no cash impact to Alibaba following completion of the transaction.
  • Alibaba will acquire newly-issued equity from Ant Financial in exchange for certain intellectual property rights owned by Alibaba exclusively related to Ant Financial.
  • The companies will terminate the current profit-sharing arrangement under which Ant Financial pays royalty and technology service fees in an amount equal to 37.5% of its pre-tax profits to Alibaba.

Now, let's take a minute to deploy our wildly popular, patented, high-tech Dick Fuld Banker-Speak Translator (BST).  As you know, the BST has long been powered by Alibaba AI and for security reasons, has recently been moved to the Alibaba Cloud.  Let's see what the Headline should have been:

Alibaba Agrees to Transfer Fake Subsidiaries and Bad Assets in Exchange for a Boatload of Promises-to-Pay and a 33% Equity Stake In Ant Financial, to be held in yet another Fake Kick-back Subsidiary.... Paving The Way For Huge Future Fake Asset Write-Ups 

You're probably wondering how the BST could possibly come up with such an outrageous analysis given the clarity of the press release.  I agree. High Tech Artificial Intelligence can yield unpredictable results.  But unfortunately, like Alibaba's AI powered search for fake goods in their ecosystem, the results are what they are.

Well, lets take a deep breath, strap on our green eye-shades and get ready for a long painful discussion of the actual, nearly unreadable, 86 page 6K filing.  I'd advise that you put on a coffee, a clean yellow legal pad so you can make notes, relax, clear in your mind and reference the sections of the filing as needed and described below..

Moreover, as you might suspect from my tone, the details in the filing seem to deviate remarkably from the press release.   To be honest, given Jay Clayton's relationship with Alibaba, as one of the primary architects of this mess, and his current role as the Regulator-In-Chief of same, I can't believe the SEC has actually made this document available to the public.  Jay's public recusal should be expected, immediate and appropriate.

Who are the Buyers and Sellers?

If you recall in my last post I mentioned the parties involved.  Luckily, as far as we can tell, only a few of the roughly 700 +/- consolidated/related entities participated in the transaction.  Generally speaking "Alibaba" is the "Seller" and "Ant" is the "Buyer".  To refresh your memory, here's the list.



Which Agreements Are Being Modified?

Here's the list as described and referenced throughout the document:

2011 Commercial Agreement,
Amended Shared Services Agreement,
Cooperation Agreement,
Cross-License Agreement,
Data Sharing Agreement,
Framework Agreement,
Offshore IP Transfer Agreement,
Offshore IP Transfer Agreement,
SME Loan Know-How License Agreements,
Subscription Agreement,
Technology Services Agreement,
Trademark Agreement
Other Agreements as needed.

That seems pretty straight forward.  The above agreements simply need to be updated to reflect this transaction between the few dozen of the companies/subsidiaries involved.


What's being Sold?

Now that we know who the "Buyers" and "Sellers" are, as well as the agreements which must be modified to facilitate this simple transaction, let's take a look at what's being sold.  The Transaction is described in Article II, Sec. 2.1 of the Agreement, beginning on page 20.  Alibaba subsidiaries, as described, are selling "Equity" (Sec. 2.1(a)) and "Assets" (Sec. 2.1(b))

The Equity to be sold (Sec. 2.1(a)) is comprised of:
  • Designated Alibaba Subsidiaries will transfer 100% of Guarantee Company (F82) to Ant Financial. 
  • Designated Alibaba Subsidiaries will transfer 100% of Chongqing Loan Company (F51) to Ant Financial.
  • Designated Alibaba Subsidiaries will transfer 100% of Libra Capital (A22) to Ant Financial.
  • Designated Alibaba Subsidiaries will transfer 100% of Alipay Singapore E-Commerce (B15) to Ant Financial.

The Assets to be sold (Sec. 2.1(a)) are comprised of:
  • Designated Alibaba Subsidiaries will transfer SME Loan Assets to Ant Financial. 
  • Designated Alibaba Subsidiaries will transfer 100% of Onshore Stage 1a Retained IP to Ant Financial. 
  • Designated Alibaba Subsidiaries will transfer 100% of Onshore Stage 1b Retained IP to Ant Financial.
  • Designated Alibaba Subsidiaries will transfer 100% of Offshore Stage 1a Retained IP to Ant Financial. 
  • Designated Alibaba Subsidiaries will transfer 100% of Offshore Stage 1b Retained IP to Ant Financial. 
  • Designated Alibaba Subsidiaries will transfer 100% of Onshore Stage 1b Retained IP to Ant Financial. 

It's typical in these agreements not to specifically describe the IP or Assets involved in the transfer, but the following disclosures on page 9 of the filing, in light of the press release, seem to be, well, a bit inconsistent:

“Offshore Stage 1a Retained IP Value” means an amount equal to RMB 11,459,466,000.00.

“Offshore Stage 1b Retained IP Value” means an amount equal to RMB 2,436,200.00.

“Onshore Stage 1a Retained IP Value” means an amount equal to RMB 741,834,000.00.

“Onshore Stage 1b Retained IP Value” means an amount equal to RMB 56,000.00.

Additionally, we note the following on page 32 of the filing:

......Purchaser shall incur obligations to pay or cause to be paid to the persons specified below (or another person designated by the Seller) ....... in consideration of the Guarantee Company (F82) Transfer, RMB 422,619,540 to be paid to Alibaba.com China (B42) and RMB 181,122,660 to be paid to Zhejiang Taobao (T51);

...... in consideration of the Chongqing Loan Company (F51) Transfer, RMB 2,574,936,000 to be paid to Hangzhou Ali Venture Capital (A54); and.....

......in consideration of the Libra Capital (A22) Transfer, US$155,181 to be paid to the Seller (the amounts set forth in this clause (a) in the aggregate, the “Finance Business Consideration”).

.......Retained Business Payment. Upon and in consideration of the Alipay Singapore E-Commerce (B15) Transfer (the “Retained Business”), the Purchaser shall incur obligations to pay or cause to be paid to Silverworld Technology (B17) US$6,307,989 (the “Retained Business Payment”) at the times set forth in Section 2.6 (or at such earlier times as the Purchaser may elect in its sole discretion).

As usual, there are all sorts of additional "expense", "tax" and transaction cost offsets described in the agreement.  The agreement also makes it clear that all taxes (if any) associated with the transaction will be the responsibility of Ant Financial.   

Oddly enough, as you recall, the press release stated that "There will be no cash impact to Alibaba following completion of the transaction."

When we add the payments due from Ant Financial described in red above, we calculate, at the current exchange rate (6.34:1) a payment due to Alibaba of US$ 2.433 Billion. for the Equities and Assets transferred.  How can this be?  I thought this was a non-cash transaction?

"Internal Financing" 

The answer, as far as we can tell, lies somewhere in the "Funding" Section of the agreement.  (Sec. 2.4 thru 2.9 of the agreement (page 32 thru 37)).  There are all sorts of "Funding Methods" described as to how Ant is going to pay Alibaba the US$ 2.433 Billion for the above described Equities/Assets. Sec 2.6 (a)(i)(A thru F).  Certain payments are made at certain times for certain things.  The terms range from "due at closing" to "sometime in the future".....here are a few of the terms:

....Upon the earliest of (i) the second anniversary of the Closing, (ii) the Purchaser Qualified IPO and (iii) the Alipay Qualified IPO, the Purchaser shall pay any remaining amount of the Finance Business Consideration that has not been paid pursuant to the preceding sentence.

.....the “Funded Amount Shortfall”),which may be repaid by the Purchaser......as determined by mutual agreement of Purchaser and the Alibaba Independent Committee no later than the earlier of (i) the one (1) year anniversary of a Purchaser Qualified IPO and (ii) the five (5) year anniversary of the date of the incurrence of the Purchaser’s obligation to pay the Funded Amount Shortfall

Section 2.6(b) ends with the following:

For the avoidance of doubt, the list of funding methods set forth above is not intended to include all possible funding methods and the unavailability or lack of feasibility of one or more (including all) of the listed funding methods shall not relieve and shall not be deemed to relieve the Purchaser, in any respect, of its obligation to fund the Funded Amount.

That's comforting.....I'm glad they have this all figured out, are looking after US Shareholders and have eliminated any doubt(s).

If I were to guess, and really, that's all we can do, I'd guess that the US$2.4 Billion is somewhere around the book value of all of the "junk" assets transferred to Ant so Alibaba does not have to recognize a gain or loss on the transfer.  The press release touted that there is no "cash impact" because the transaction is internally financed.  Of course, this type of transaction screams for another deployment of the BST!......Here's what's the Alibaba Management Team is up to.

"We gotta get US$2.4 Billion of Bad Loans and Capitalized Intellectual property off the books before this blows up.  This crap should have been expensed/written-off long ago but we didn't want it to hit the bottom line.  Now we've came up with this cockamamie scheme to 'sell' this junk to Ant.  Nobody would finance this mess so we are just taking back whatever cash we can scrape up and Ant's promise to pay at some point in the future.  So we've converted US$2.4 Billion of financial vapor to a 'rock solid' commitment from a related piggy bank that US Shareholders know nothing about!  Genius" 

Issuance of Ant Financial Securities (the 33% Stake)

The issuance of the Ant Financial 33% stake to a newly formed "Seller Designated Investment Entity"  is described in Sec. 2.3 (pages 27 thru 32).  I'd assume that the "Seller Designated Investment Entity" would be wholly owned by Alibaba and a fully consolidated entity, but as we've seen in the past, all sorts of "surprise ownership" interests tend to pop up in these deals and the Agreement, unfortunately, is silent as to the ownership of this new Investment Entity.  All we know for sure is that "within seventy-five (75) days following the Amendment Date, the Seller shall, and shall cause its Subsidiaries, to establish the Seller Designated Investment Entity" (page 31)  Luckily, US shareholders are used to these "dilution-al" interests just popping up from time to time. so it's probably  no big deal.

So let's take a look at where we're at so far....here's a very summarized chart of the transaction:




























Summary of the transaction's Balance Sheet impact:

  • Alibaba exchanges $2.4 Billion of  "Junk Assets" for an equal value of Cash and Obligations Receivable (C&OR)  No change in total Balance Sheet valuation from this transaction.
  • Ant Financial Exchanges  $2.4 Billion for C&OR for an equal amount of "Junk Assets".  No  change in Ant's Balance Sheet from this transaction.  
  • Ant Financial exchanges 33% Ownership for C&OR.  Balance Sheet increases by $2.4 Billion.  Debit to C&OR, Credit to Capital.  
  • Alibaba exchanges $2.4 Billion C&OR for Interest in New Entity.  No change in Balance Sheet value.  Debit to "Investees" and Credit to C&OR.
  • "New Entity" book value is $2.4 Billion.  Debit to "Investees" and Credit to Capital. 

Note that the above transaction creates $4.8 Billion in new Balance Sheet book value.  $2.4 Billion in Ant for the 33% Equity Issued and $2.4 Billion in the "New Entity".   Interestingly, no additional economic value has been created and no outside funding or resources enter the picture.  We're just moving journal entries around and creating "equity" and book value.

Ok?....so far so good?  Let's Continue?

The Accounting:  

Although the above are just guesses as to what's going to be reflected on the next 6-K, I'm sure that a transaction of this magnitude was well thought through (or not) and the Alibaba Accounting Department has absolutely nailed down the exact valuations of the Intellectual Property to be transferred as well as the current book/carrying value of same.  They've also undoubtedly established the value of their brand new 33% Interest in Ant Financial (Just like they eventually did with Alibaba Pictures, Alibaba Health, Cainiao and the other forty or so acquisitions where they booked huge gains, locked in Amber, in the dark of night on the Alibaba balance sheet.

Unfortunately, none of these values or the underlying methodology are fully discussed in the filing, so we'll just have to make some more educated guesses as to the impact on the financial statements, once the initial funding round(s) commence.

On the other hand, the Alibaba PR department is absolutely on top of their game and, as usual, way ahead of the Alibaba Accounting department, immediately leaking to CNBC and other outlets, through unnamed sources, that based on the next $5 Billion (5%) funding round, the valuation of Ant Financial will be roughly $100 Billion!  Can you imagine the wealth that has been generated overnight because of this funding!  Every Alibaba shareholder is destined to be rich beyond his/her wildest dreams. 

Hypothetically, of course, here's how these "funding rounds" go.  Analysis is again provided by the (BST).
  • Jack & Joe call some of their buddies (Softbank, CITC, Temasek, Sequoia, Tencent, Evergrande, Wanda, etc.....the "usual suspects") and make the pitch...."Hey we have this amazing opportunity for you to get in on the ground floor of this once in a lifetime deal....yadayadayada.... We want to sell you 5% of Ant Financial at a really inflated price and we'll make it worth your while. We will 'lever up' and book some big time 'valuation gains' that those dopey US Investors won't understand because they are all wrapped up in ARPU's, AMU's, RUAMFR's and FU's."
  • The "Usual Suspects" as always, respond...."tell me more!"
  • Again, hypothetically of course, Jack and Joe respond by offering.... "Here’s the deal…. just provide a note payable (no cash required), we will sell you the equity (5%) and put some sort of a great, totally unrelated kickback scheme in place. Maybe we’ll do a funding round for you or pay you for some Intellectual Property (there certainly is a lot of intellectual property floating around all of a sudden) or some other device to loot all of that Ant/Money Market cash that is actually the property of the hard working Chinese people!
  • The "Usual Suspects" ponder this difficult decision for about a millisecond and whammo!  Ant Financial is immediately worth $100 Billion!
Since, again, the Alibaba Accounting department has either been falling down on the job or far too secretive, we have to take it upon ourselves to try to determine if the brand new, leaked $100 Billion valuation is reasonable.

What Are Ant Financial's Earnings?

Luckily since everything is absolutely accurate and transparent in Alibaba's SEC filings, even though they don't describe this expense/accrual in the quarterly 6-K's, we can easily scroll through the most recent 20-F and zero-in on the exact annual amount that Ant Financial is crediting to Alibaba for the 37.5% Profit Sharing Agreement (and thereby calculate the pre-tax income of Ant Financial):


March 31st, 2017 YE 20-F
(Conveniently Located on Pg. 193 of the filing, which ties to the Income Statement)

In fiscal years 2015, 2016 and 2017, under the Alipay IPLA, we recognized royalty and software technology services fee income, net of costs incurred by our company, amounting to RMB1,667 million, RMB1,122 million and RMB2,086 million (US$303 million), respectively, as other income.

....There you have it....37.5% of Ant Financials Pre-Tax Income is $303 Million.....But wait.....this figure combines both the IPLA and the 37.5% "Royalty" profit sharing agreement and is "net of costs".....lets go further...

(Conveniently located at F-40, on page. 287 of the filing)

4. Significant equity transactions, restructuring transactions, mergers and acquisitions and equity investments (Continued)

(b) Restructuring of Payment Services (Continued)


In connection with the 2014 SAPA, the Company also entered into an amended intellectual property license agreement with Alipay ("amended Alipay IPLA"), pursuant to which the Company licenses certain intellectual property and provides certain software technology services to Alipay and the Transferred Business. Under the amended Alipay IPLA, the Company will receive royalty streams and a service fee (collectively, the "Profit Share Payments") which will be paid at least annually, amounting to the sum of an expense reimbursement plus 37.5% of the consolidated pre-tax income of Ant Financial Services, subject to certain adjustments. In addition, if the Company acquires any equity interest in Ant Financial Services, the Company will transfer an agreed portion of the underlying intellectual property to Ant Financial Services at the time of such equity issuance. At the same time, the Profit Share Payments will also be reduced in proportion to such equity issuances made to the Company.


Income in connection with the royalty fee and software technology services fee under the Intellectual Property License and Software Technology Services Agreement and the Profit Share Payments, net of costs incurred by the Company, of RMB1,667 million, RMB1,122 million and RMB2,086 million were recorded in other income, net in the consolidated income statements for the years ended March 31, 2015, 2016 and 2017, respectively (Note 22).

....Rats, that's still the combined figure ........lets continue...

(Conveniently located at F-90, on page. 323 of the filing)


22. Related party transactions (Continued) (i)

In 2011, the Company entered into an Intellectual Property License and Software Technology Services Agreement with Alipay whereby the Company licenses certain intellectual property and provides certain software technology services to Alipay in exchange for a royalty fee and software technology services fee in an amount equal to the costs incurred by the Company in providing the software technology services plus 49.9% of the consolidated pre-tax income of Alipay and its subsidiaries (Note 4(b)), effective from December 2011. In 2014, the Intellectual Property License and Software Technology Services Agreement was terminated and the Company entered into the amended Alipay IPLA with Ant Financial Services. Under the amended Alipay IPLA, the Company receives the Profit Share Payments amounting to the sum of an expense reimbursement plus 37.5% of the consolidated pre-tax income of Ant Financial Services, subject to certain adjustments (Note 4(b)), effective from August 2014.


Royalty fee and software technology services fee under the Intellectual Property License and Software Technology Services Agreement and the Profit Share Payments were recognized in consolidated income statements, net of the costs incurred for the provision of the software technology services reimbursed by Alipay. The amounts reimbursed by Ant Financial Services to the Company were RMB486 million, RMB274 million and RMB245 million for the years ended March 31, 2015, 2016 and 2017, respectively.


....Geeezzz......that's weird...nowhere in the 20-F do they come right out and say that the Profit Sharing Amount (37.5% of Ant Financial's Pre-Tax Income) paid to Alibaba is exactly $xxx.xx.  That would have been really helpful and so easy to do.  Everything Alibaba management seems to report is always hidden, questionable and subject to adjustments and offsets. 

Here's the schedule that should have been produced and included in the 20-F....and every 6-K for that matter:












So, let's give Alibaba Management the benefit of the doubt.  Alipay, with it's more than 900 million registered users (per Jack in his Lara Logan Interview in 2014), is the very definition of a monopolistic/mature business.  Moreover, even though Joe Tsai makes interesting comments like "Alipay daily active users have more than doubled in the current quarter" (min 36:20 of the 2/1/18 investor call) it would have been nice to know what the number of Alipay users actually is what they've "doubled from".  Let's say, simply for the sake of argument and by all anecdotal accounts that Alipay is indeed ubiquitous in China.  Like a swarm of locusts, it's everywhere.  Consequently, meteoric, start-up-like growth should be a distant glimmer in the rear view mirror and revenue and income growth, like any established financial firm, will be joined at the hip to the Chinese economy.

If we give management the benefit of the doubt and assume that all of the RMB1,841 is attributable to the 37.5% "Profit Sharing" which is absolutely not guaranteed given all of the evolving terminology, obfuscation, offsets, adjustments and weasel words described in the above footnotes #4 and #22, we can try to back into Ant's Before Tax Net Income ($714 Million), apply a tax rate (Alibaba's tax rate is 23%) to Calculate/Estimate "Earnings" ($549 Million) and a P/E.  At a $100 Billion Market Cap we calculate a P/E of 182.  Hmmmm.....seems a bit pricey to me.



When we compare Ant Financial's estimated P/E of 182 at a $100 Billion Market Cap to a few other prominent Payment Processors, we can conclude that the $100 Billion value might indeed be a tad steep.  As described,  even if we assign a historically high P/E of 30,  that would peg the valuation at $16.6 Billion.....a far cry from the Alibaba PR Department's press release

As far as I can tell, the first representation, by Alibaba Management, as to the "notional value" of Ant Financial came via a schedule and footnote in the May 5th, 2016 Investor Presentation (Page 23) just last year.   Footnote below:

http://www.alibabagroup.com/en/ir/presentations/pre160505.pdf

(3) Ant Financial valuation based on reported valuation of USD 60 billion in media; Alibaba Group receives 37.5% of Ant’s pre-tax income now, and if regulations allow, Alibaba Group is entitled to acquire up to a 33% equity interests in Ant Financial. For conservative purpose, 33% is used in calculating Alibaba Group’s economics in Ant Financial here.   

As I mentioned at the time, this, I believe, was the first time in history that an SEC filing claimed that Bloomberg/"Media" was the source of a $60 Billion Asset valuation.  Generally, since contra to popular opinion, news outlets don't just make things up, it would not be a reach to presume that these valuations are most likely the product of the Alibaba PR Machine, issued through anonymous, unnamed sources.

Alibaba's Financial Statements After the "Funding Round"

So let's say, just for fun, that the US$5 Billion funding round happens in the next quarter.  Let's say that somehow, Alibaba Management actually convinces PWC that the funding round actually meets IFRS Criteria for revaluation and write up.  I smell a big accounting fee coming!

To that end, I've listed the proposed Journal Entry and revised Balance Sheet Below, all things being equal, as if the transaction had taken place in the last quarter.  My hands were actually trembling from the absurdity as I was typing up the schedule:



Based on the above we see that back in 2014, after roughly fifteen years in existence, after all of that effort, Alibaba had accumulated only US$18 Billion in Book Value, had virtually no retained earnings to speak of ($190 Million) and, by all accounts, had maxed out their lines of credit.  Simultaneously, by some fortuitous, amazing, happenstance, Alibaba Management hooked up with Jay Clayton, Sullivan & Cromwell, US & Swiss Investment Bankers and in less than four years, based on the above projections of the presumed re-valuation of Ant Financial, Alibaba will have created more than US$142 Billion in Book Value.

Further note that in a preemptive effort to cut off the trolls, I freely admit that I know absolutely nothing about Chinese Tax Law, so the $5 Billion Deferred Tax impact is purely a guess.  The provision is for illustrative purposes only.  For you Chinese Tax Pros out there, feel free to make that entry whatever you'd like it to be.

As we can see, most of the book value, will continue to be, as I've long opined, housed in opaque, overvalued "Questionable Assets" (Investments & Securities relating to "Investees". Intangibles, Goodwill & Land Use Rights), which, if Alibaba Management actually has the testicular fortitude to value Ant Financial at $100 Billion, would bring "Questionable Assets" up to US$89 Billion (63% of the balance sheet).  Also keep in mind that the "Newly Formed Entity" will be written up as well based on the increase in the Ant Valuation.  So, if they can actually pull this off, $66 Billion in additional Book Value (i.e. collateral) and $56 Billion of  Additional "Equity" would be created as well.  Also remember, when we write something up (e.g. Alibaba Pictures, Cainiao, Alibaba Health, etc.) we can always book valuation gains that hit the Income Statement.  So income of $56 Billion would be created, out of thin air, overnight, as well!

Oddly, there is absolutely no change in the underlying businesses.  The same fake goods are being sold and paid for via the same Alipay accounts.  The same bad micro-loans and WMP's are being written and the same rapidly expanding credit risk continues to be hidden.  Absolutely no new "Economic Value" has been created by the Alibaba/Ant "Acquisition" transactions.

I ABSOLUTELY LOVE IFRS ACCOUNTING!!



OPTIONAL READING:  WHY JAY CLAYTON SHOULD PUBLICLY RECUSE HIMSELF FROM ANY ONGOING OR FUTURE ALIBABA INVESTIGATION.  

Revisiting a Relevant Prior Post

Last week, a couple of my readers revisited a really fun, June 2016 post I had done (long before Jay Clayton was being considered for the SEC Chairmanship) and they called it to my attention.  I had forgotten about its relevance for the most part until they reminded me of just how pertinent it has become in light of the silliness and possible financial misrepresentations that I've described above.

The post, in my humble opinion, took a light-hearted, humorous, yet moderately pissed-off look at the now presumably tainted relationship between Jay Clayton, who had been privy to and presumably instrumental in drafting/designing the Alibaba Responses to the SEC inquiries on the "Simon Xie "deals back in the day. ("Simon Xie" aka Xie Shihuang is one of the current "Framework Parties" in the Ant Deal.)   Again, now that Jay is in charge of the regulation of this ticking time bomb, I felt that we should absolutely revisit same.  When you click on the Alibaba Correspondence please note that Mr. Clayton is either the author of, or copied on, each ludicrous document/response. 

******************************************************************
Link to the June 2016 Post - Go to "SEC Process".  Relevant Text Below
https://deep-throat-ipo.blogspot.com/2016/06/follow-up-thoughts-on-i-would-never.html

SEC Process

These investigations, again, by their very nature are private matters.  Both the SEC and the subject of the investigation normally make no public disclosures, nor do they have anything to gain by doing so. However, we might be able to shed some light on the process by combing through the correspondence leading up to the IPO.  I've attached a few of the documents below for your review if you choose to take the time:

Example - 60 page SEC document Q&A 6/16/14 Response to 5/6/14 F1 fiing.
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1577552/000119312514237452/filename1.htm

Example - 35 page SEC document Q&A 7/11/14 response to 7/3/14 Amended F1
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1577552/000119312514266474/filename1.htm

Correspondence - 8/6/14
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1577552/000119312514298625/filename1.htm

Correspondence - 8/12/16
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1577552/000119312514306858/filename1.htm

Correspondence 8/22/14
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1577552/000119312514318466/filename1.htm

Without getting into the gory details, I'll discuss the general format of the Q&A and then interpret some of my favorite interrogatories through the magic of my Dick Fuld Banker Speak Translator (BST) (patent pending):

Q&A Format:

SEC: "Dear Alibaba Management & Counsel, we see you've disclosed/described (Insert odd, unsupported metric here) which may or may not have a bearing on (Insert odd, unsupported additional metrics here).


BABA Respondent: "Thank you for the wonderful, insightful question"  From this point the response takes one (or more) of the following three possible directions:

  1. "I'm sorry, it appears that you just don't understand what we are doing in our business model.  You must understand, in China, eCommerce, financial reporting, mathematics perhaps even the laws of physics are totally different than they are in the US.  Let us try to help you get past your ignorance.  After all, the Chinese people invented mathematics well before Capitalism even existed.  Don't worry, we'll get you through this.  Please see the attached additional odd, unsupported, made-up, metrics."
  2. "I'm sorry, what you are asking us for is impossible.  Because of our laws in China we simply can't comply with your request.  Selling fake tchotchkes on the Internet is a highly guarded State Secret and the politburo will not allow us to discuss the matter.  Let's just move on and call it a day.  Once again, we'd love to help out, but our hands are tied, our deepest regrets.  I'm sure you understand."
  3. "I'm sorry, we've been advised by our Public Accountants, Investment Bankers and our Legal Counsel that we don't have to give that to you.  We don't think it's necessary and you don't need it.  You wouldn't know what to do with the information, or understand it anyway.  So that's that. Next question please."

Now, as promised, lets run a few of my favorite interrogatories through the BST and see what we get:

This one addresses a US$1 Billion dollar "loan" of Alibaba funds to be made directly to Simon Xie, Jack's buddy for "strategic investment purposes".  (Page 3 of the August 12th, 2014 Correspondence cited above)

SEC: We note the disclosure on page 226 regarding the RMB6.5 billion loan arrangement with Simon Xie. We also note that a company controlled by Jack Ma will serve as a general partner of the PRC partnership that will receive indirectly the proceeds of such loan. Please provide us with a detailed analysis of the nature of the loan and the extent to which the provisions of Section 13(k) of the Exchange Act are applicable to the loan. Your analysis should address both Mr. Xie and Mr. Ma.

SEC - BST - WTF??.....you are taking $1 Billion of Shareholder money and giving it to Jack's buddy?  Is this thing Jack Ma's own personal piggy bank?  

I'm not going to bother posting the entire Alibaba response.  It's long winded and barely understandable.  You can certainly muddle through the filing if you are so inclined. However, to keep things moving, here's the BST version of what they said:

Alibaba Respondent: - BST    "Ohhhh!.....I see what you are getting at.  You've got it all wrong. Here's what's really going on.  The loan to Simon isn't a 13(k) 'personal' loan....it's a 'business' loan!  See, even though the money is going to him, Simon is going to take the money and contribute it to a partnership that he and Jack have cooked up, and once the money is sufficiently laundered, the partnership is going to 'invest' it in Wasu Media, since Wasu media has a strategic relationship with Alibaba.  Jack isn't getting the money (It's going to a partnership) so he's not in violation of 13(k) either!  That's why we did it this way!....That way, Jack and Simon get a billion dollar loan, they can do whatever they want with the proceeds, maybe invest in Wasu, maybe not.   Moreover Simon isn't a qualifying executive under 13(k)...he's not a director or 'senior' manager.....we just want to give him a BILLION DOLLARS since he's a good guy.....he's just one of five 'strategic' vice presidents!   Who knows, if this works we might give all five of them a BILLION DOLLARS each!  US Shareholders are really generous that way.  That way all of the VP's can get access to Billions of US Shareholder Dollars, for 'strategic purposes', pay the interest from loan principal until the investments pay off (or not) and nobody is the wiser!   Isn't this an AWESOME IDEA! If you guys sign off on this one we will be actively looking for homeless people to start partnerships with Jack.  We understand that in America you can go to jail for things like this, but in China it's SOP.  We're sure glad you understand how this works now.  Thanks for asking about it."


Here's a follow up on pg 7 of the same August 12th, 2014 Document.

SEC: Please address in this risk factor any potential material conflicts of interest between you and Simon Xie and expand this risk factor to discuss any potential material conflicts of interest resulting from the manner in which you plan to invest in Wasu Media Holdings Co., Ltd.  It appears that the disclosure required by Item 6.A of Form 20-F is applicable to Simon Xie. In this regard, we note your apparent dependence upon Mr. Xie based on his role as one of your founders and as a member of your management, as well as his equity interests in Alipay, your material VIEs, and the partnership through which you plan to invest in Wasu Media Holdings Co. Please provide the disclosure required by Item 6.A of Form 20-F and in doing so disclose Mr. Xie’s roles and responsibilities in your company and where Mr. Xie falls within your management structure.

SEC - BST: "So you are making the loan to the partnership owned by Simon, Jack and Yuzhu Shi?  The partnership is going to buy the stock of Wasu media?  That's the same Yuzhu Shi, the guy who went bust trying to build the tallest skyscraper in China (that was never actually built) and then took a video game company, Giant Interactive public on the NYSE, raised $1 Billion on the IPO, milked it for all it was worth and took it private in China at a deep discount with US Shareholders left holding the bag?.......is that the same Yuzhu Shi that you are jumping into bed with on both Wasu and Yunfeng Capital??   And you don't see any conflict of interest here?  Really?" 

Here's the BST version of the Alibaba Response:

Alibaba Respondent: - BST  "Wowww....you guys are really sharp!  You've actually read through the whole filing and you know your securities law to boot!  Ok, here's what's really going on.  You think that Simon actually works here and that his employment would make him an employee 'upon whose work the company is dependent' as defined in Item 6.A of Form 20-F.   Again, you've got it all wrong.  Simon, is a peon, a nobody, he pushes a broom around and occasionally opens the mail....that's it!  In fact, if you don't let us structure this deal this way we're going to fire his sorry ass so that there is absolutely no conflict under 13(k).  Of course, we're still going to give him a Billion dollars,  just 'cuz we want to and you can't stop us. Moreover,  Yuzhu Shi is a wealthy visionary and great man.  He was able to amass a tremendous fortune by creating fake businesses out of nothing, pulling all of the cash out of them and selling the decaying shells to suckers....uh....I mean fortunate investors.  Anyway, all of these people are safe in China and you have no jurisdiction over them.  So mind your own beeswax."

The May 26th, 2016 20-F

Fast forward to the 20F - pg 40.  They did indeed "fire his sorry ass" to conform to 13(k) on this loan. I guess the other four "Strategic VP's" could easily pick up the slack.  However, it looks like the actual structure of the deal has changed significantly.   Per the recent 20-F, the RMB 6.9 Billion (US$1.06 Billion) loan was actually made to Simon by an unnamed PRC Bank.  Alibaba pledged RMB 7.3 Billion (US$1.12 Billion) of "Wealth Management Products" which are presumably carried on their balance sheet somewhere to guarantee the loan.  Alibaba also set up a RMB 2.0 Billion (US$ 300 Million) Credit Facility to Simon so he can afford to pay the substantial interest on the bank loan. 

Here are a couple of questions I might ask about this reconstituted transaction if I were one of the SEC attorneys investigating this mess:

  • Where was the money that required the pledge/guarantee of Alibaba assets actually invested?  did it all go to Wasu or did Simon or Jack skim a bit off the top for vacation homes in the Adirondacks and/or Caymans?....Hey, don't get upset....I'm just asking a question.
  • Where did the "Wealth Management Products" come from?  What are they?  How did they come about and where are they on the balance sheet?  Did Alibaba buy a bunch of wonderful small business loans (aka non-performing) from ANT/Alipay using US Shareholder Money?  Is that the collateral pledged for the loan to Simon?  After all, it's a BILLION dollars 
  • What is the interest rate on the PRC Bank Loan to Simon?  What are the terms of this loan?  Which Bank is it?  They won't even disclose which banker was dumb enough to do this deal?
  • Does Simon really need a $300 Million Credit facility to pay interest on a billion dollar loan?  Even at 10% Simple Interest that's 3 years of Interest payments.  So whatever the hell the terms of the "investment" was in Wasu, it isn't flowing any cash?
  • WTF???....(This last question is just rhetorical and would add no value to the investigation).

Note: Wasu is a public company on the Shanghai Stock exchange.  On the date of the SEC Correspondence (August 12th, 2014) it was trading at $29/share.  It hit a high of $59/share in June of 2015 (Before the crash) and it's trading at $19/share today (a 33% haircut from August 2014).  The Market Cap today is about $4 Billion (Down from $6 Billion).  We don't know anything about the financial prospects of Wasu or the Ma, Xie, Shi partnership.  The only things we are certain of :

  • The value of the collateral (Wasu) underlying Simon's margin loan has declined substantially and is most likely under water. 
  • Based on the structure, Alibaba (and consequently US Shareholders) have credit risk by virtue of the pledge of (quite possibly dog-shit) "Wealth Management Products" to an unnamed PRC Bank, if for some reason Wasu stumbles into some cash flow or collateral valuation problems.  Apparently they already have since there is now a magical Alibaba credit facility in place to pay Simon's Interest on the PRC Bank "loan".
Perhaps that's why the SEC is looking into this?  I'm just sayin'....
**************************************************************************

To cap off the Simon Xie discussion, one of my well informed readers also posted:

One more thing, a paragraph from the 2014 SEC correspondence regarding Simon Xie that you translated to BST:

"With regard to the language of Item 6.A of Form 20-F requiring disclosure of certain information concerning “employees such as scientists or designers upon whose work the company is dependent,” the Company respectfully submits that this requirement applies to employees whose specific skills or technical expertise make them indispensable to a company’s operations and where the loss of such an employee (who, by the nature of his skills and expertise, is not readily replaceable) would materially affect a company’s ability to engage in its core business. A plain reading of the language of Item 6.A, which refers to scientists and designers as the representative examples of such employees, as well as a review of past comment letters issued by the Staff in other transactions confirms this view. The functions Mr. Xie serves cited by the Staff, including his function as a minority VIE equity holder, are roles that could be filled by any trusted long-time employee, and these are not roles, such as those of a key scientist, engineer or designer, that involve a unique skillset or high level of training that render the Company “dependent” upon such employee. As one of five vice presidents involved in domestic China investments, his role is to identify and execute investments, but he cannot be called someone upon whom the Company is dependent."

Note the last sentence. I think this important point was lost in your still excellent BST translation. How can a man who was one of Alibaba's 18 founders and whose "ROLE IS TO IDENTIFY AND EXECUTE INVESTMENTS" NOT be someone on whom the company is dependent? Does Alibaba not depend on the success of Xie's investments?

If we take Alibaba at their word, Xie's investment abilities are so run-of-the-mill that he could be replaced by a monkey and Alibaba would be no worse for wear. If this is true, what does this tell us about the quality of Alibaba's investments in China that so many BABA "investors" are so willing to believe are phenomenal even in the absence of coherent financial statements (Xie "serves as a vice president on the Company’s domestic China investment team and is involved in projects related to the Company’s domestic China acquisition and investment activities.")? And if it's not true that Xie could be replaced by a monkey (or more realistically a janitor as you suggested), why isn't this a violation of the law?

Yes that appears to be the case. Not comforting.

And sorry to blow up the comments, but another infuriating blip of information:

Just one month, ONE MONTH, after Alibaba submitted those answers about Xie to the SEC, arguing that he is a nobody (in a letter cc'd to future SEC Chairman Jay Clayton), Reuters ran this article:

https://www.reuters.com/article/alibaba-group-ipo-xie/insight-simon-xie-jack-mas-unassuming-lieutenant-at-alibaba-idUSL1N0RC0A820140914

Excerpt: "But for investors in Alibaba Group Holding Ltd’s potentially record initial public offering, Simon Xie, a co-founder and vice president, represents one of the e-commerce company’s most important figures: he’s the only individual besides Executive Chairman Jack Ma who owns the domestic Chinese companies and holds the operating licenses that underpin Alibaba’s corporate structure.

Alongside Ma, who holds the lion’s share of those domestic firms, Xie wields full legal sway over the onshore entities and the critical contracts that link them with the New York-listed vehicle.

Yet much remains unknown about Xie, and the unusual shareholding arrangement has puzzled even high-level insiders. Some employees, said a former executive who worked closely with Xie, jokingly refer to the unassuming 45-year-old as shoufu - or “top millionaire” - even though he is not among the very top Alibaba shareholders."...

“Simon Xie is clearly the most important person in Alibaba who is not part of the steering committee,” said Fredrik Oqvist, the Beijing-based founder and CEO of ChinaRAI, a consulting firm that advises hedge and mutual funds. “He pops up everywhere, yet he’s elusive.”

The rest of the article basically says Xie is not ambitious so was passed over as a top leader, and that he is unswervingly loyal to Ma.

Hmmm. A pliant, elusive lieutenant who "pops up everywhere", and whose role is clearly lied about to the SEC. Doesn't seem fishy at all.

BREAKING NEWS!

Dateline 2/20/18 -  Guangzhou - Today, it was announced by unnamed sources familiar with the deal that Alibaba (NYSE:BABA), along with a consortium of unnamed investors, has entered into a definitive agreement in principle to acquire "Germany".  The deal will be accomplished through multiple funding rounds where the first such transaction is structured to be completed by the end of 2019. The company is expected to purchase 0.001% of  Germany for US$1 Billion, valuing the German economy at US$100 Trillion, which will be immediately reflected in the Alibaba financial statements regardless of whether the deal actually closes or not.  Joe Tsai was heard to say, again through unnamed sources, that:

"Germany will be an integral part of Alibaba's eCommerce ecosystem.  If all goes as expected with our Germany acquisition, we fully anticipate moving ahead, acquiring and integrating Australia into our 'New Retail' model sometime prior to 2025."  

BABA's stock was up $35.00 in active trading on the announcement.  Angela Merkel was unavailable for comment.

******************************************************************************
Additional Reading


$60 Billion Valuation - Forbes, April 2014
https://www.forbes.com/sites/annrutledge/2016/04/27/the-case-for-valuing-ant-financial-at-usd-60-billion/#4b22602b218a

Bloomberg Article, June 2017 - Ant worth $74.5 Billion using the RMB 2,086 "Profit Sharing Figure"  Alibaba Management - "No Comment".
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-06-22/jack-ma-s-ant-financial-nearly-doubles-profits-amid-deal-push

$100 Billion valuation as of 2/9/18....The Alibaba P/R Department is once again working Overtime.
https://www.cnbc.com/2018/02/09/ant-financial-to-raise-5-billion-in-equity.html

Financial Times Analysis - Alibaba/Ant Deal
https://www.ft.com/content/6e3c2c1a-0769-11e8-9650-9c0ad2d7c5b5

The 86 page, February 1st, 2018 "Amendment to Share and Asset Purchase Agreement" filing.

Educated guesses....

$100 Billion valuation....Tha Alibaba P/R Department is once again working Overtime.
https://www.cnbc.com/2018/02/09/ant-financial-to-raise-5-billion-in-equity.html

Tuesday, January 23, 2018

If the Gettysburg Address had been "Tweeted"....

You'd have to have been living in a cave if you've not noticed how the delivery, the medium, the style and the content or our communication has changed over the years.  As you might recall, one-half score and seven years or so ago, Google's Peter Norvig came up with a wonderful parody of the Gettysburg Address as a Powerpoint presentation.   My recollection of this piece was so  memorable and entertaining that today, in honor of Mr. Norvig and as a salute to our brand new, self inflicted government shutdown, re-opening, and potential re-shut-down looming again on February 8th, I thought I'd have a little fun with "Tweeting":

The Gettysburg Address via  "Tweet"....

Abe: "Fourscore and seven years ago our fathers brought forth, on this continent, a new nation, conceived in liberty, and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal."

Tweet: "87 years ago we started the USA.  Today, SLAVERY!  NOT GOOD!  But some of the slave owners are probably good people...."

Abe: "Now we are engaged in a great civil war, testing whether that nation, or any nation so conceived, and so dedicated, can long endure. We are met on a great battle-field of that war. We have come to dedicate a portion of that field, as a final resting-place for those who here gave their lives, that that nation might live."

Tweet: "We have a VERY DANGEROUS SOUTHERN BORDER.  I feel bad for these dead Gettysburg losers.  AMERICANS ARE WINNERS!!  BUILD A WALL!  WIN! WIN!"

Abe: "It is altogether fitting and proper that we should do this. But, in a larger sense, we cannot dedicate, we cannot consecrate—we cannot hallow—this ground. The brave men, living and dead, who struggled here, have consecrated it far above our poor power to add or detract."

Tweet: "AMERICA FIRST!  CIVIL WAR....NOT MY FAULT!  NOT MY PROBLEM!"

Abe: "The world will little note, nor long remember what we say here, but it can never forget what they did here. It is for us the living, rather, to be dedicated here to the unfinished work which they who fought here have thus far so nobly advanced.

Tweet: "GETTYSBURG NEVER HAPPENED!  FAKE NEWS!"

Abe: "It is rather for us to be here dedicated to the great task remaining before us—that from these honored dead we take increased devotion to that cause for which they here gave the last full measure of devotion—that we here highly resolve that these dead shall not have died in vain—that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom, and that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth."

Tweet: "Stock Market's UP!  Unemployment DOWN!  Taxes DOWN! Black people have more jobs than ever! Jobs coming back. USA...USA....USA!"

http://rmc.library.cornell.edu/gettysburg/good_cause/transcript.htm

To be honest, and I'm serious, I'm not sure which, the original, the PowerPoint or the Tweet is more effective.  In context, they each get the job done, impacting their intended audience in their own particular way.

Although (of course), I wasn't there, my guess would be that the audience at Gettysburg, surrounded by their wounded loved ones, shortly after burying their dead, had a much more personal, emotional, tragic and memorable experience than those who click through PowerPoints in a conference room or scan through Tweets on their phones at the airport.  Lincoln's words were more personal to those souls who endured and survived Gettysburg than anything most of us could possibly, or hopefully ever will, imagine.

The point I'm making is that we all receive (and perceive) messages based on our personal experiences.  Our own experiences filter and interpret the message.  Whether you are an insurance salesman, economist/blogger; a Senator, investor, accountant or banker, a foreign government official/operative/diplomat, a soldier deployed overseas in harms way; recently or chronically unemployed, or like most of us, just trying to make your way, as best you can on this big blue marble, we all hear the same words, but we hear them differently.  We choose to hear what we want to hear.  The "truth" has become malleable.

Somehow we've gotten to the point where concepts like good and bad, right and wrong, accurate and inaccurate are an opinion, rather than an absolute.  As we sit on our overstuffed La-Z-Boy couches in front of our Facebook feeds, Tweets and favorite TV talking heads, oblivious and sheltered from any point of view that conflicts with our own limited, preconceived experience, we are fitfully outraged by attacks on our version of the truth.  Whether Democrat or Republican, we agonize over our leadership under assault by philistine-barbarians who don't understand the issues and lie about the facts (as we see them).  Everyone who disagrees with us and/or threatens our own vested interest is consequently labeled  either a bigoted, war mongering racist or a flag burning anti-American liberal.  When we hear something we disagree with, our immediate response is "Oh Yeah!....so's your Mother!" If/when we objectively consider another persons point of view our like-minded constituents deem us to be spineless and weak. Open minded compromise is a wimp's disease and must be eradicated.

We fret over whether the current government shutdown will disrupt our day.  Worry consumes us as we wonder whether our government benefits will be delayed, or services we depend on will be reduced or disrupted.  We feel threatened by evil people from mysterious foreign lands who will surely bomb us and/or take our jobs if given half a chance, even though we've never met any of these people and have no intention of doing so.  We wait patiently, even though we've done nothing over the last decade to improve our personal circumstance, for some mythical person to walk through our front door and offer us the job of a lifetime.  Finally, in the absence of any productive endeavor to fill the void,  we spend our time analyzing the never ending flow of misdirection, develop deep "E-relationships" with like-minded anonymous Facebook "friends" and bitch about whose fault "it" all is, and of course, who we should blame.

Our Disfunctional Government

I believe that this might be the first (and hopefully only) time that I'll ever say anything in this blog that could be even remotely considered "political" in nature.  This blog is dedicated solely to the examination of "general silliness" in the US Financial Markets.  On the other hand, when "general political silliness" impacts financial markets I, for better or worse, feel an obligation to speak up.

Right now, our government has been "shut down" and reopened with another "shut down" ominously looming on February 8th.  To me, "shut down" is a bit of an oxymoron since nearly every government service in America remains operational.  Every government service is apparently deemed to be "essential".  Checks are still being written, mail is being delivered and most government employees are being paid (or their wages are being accrued).  Troops are still deployed and the missile silos are still manned.  Of course, if you planned a trip to the Smithsonian or Yellowstone, you might be out of luck, at least for now.  This, in my humble opinion is a teeny-tiny price to pay for a front row seat to watch our muddling democracy in action.

How did this "shut down" come about?  Right now, we can point to our wonderfully amazing two party system of government where, unfortunately, neither side is willing to give ground on, well, just about anything.  The Republican "blow it up and fix it later" approach (blowing things up is always more fun than fixing them!) has run head long into the Democrats' "if we just spend more money with no accountability to keep everyone happy everything will eventually work out" plan.

As we've witnessed first hand, based on the last election, the Democrat's plan has been violently disrupted, leaving them scrambling for a "win".  Oddly enough, they've chosen to draw a line in the sand with......wait for it.... the Dreamers!  Yeah!.....that's the ticket....that's something they can publicize and win!  Forget about fixing healthcare, funding for infrastructure or education or stopping the most regressive tax cut in history......the Dreamers is the issue on which the Democrats will make their last stand.

From high altitude, we can see the logic.  This should have been a no-brainer.  This should have been an "easy" compromise and an easy political victory for the minority Democrats.  They could finally tell their constituents "Hey!.....we did something!".  Moreover, with a compromise, there's no additional cost to extending/keeping DACA.  This could have been agreed to behind closed doors, slipped into the appropriation at the 11th hour, as so much usually is, before anyone has a chance to read it, understand it or Tweet about it, and nobody would have known (or cared) that much about it.  Business as usual.  Yet, in our current politically charged "win at all cost" environment, our legislators chose to publicize this debate in a presumed, yet ham handed effort on the part of both parties to rile up their respective bases.   The result is that they've shown the American people that they are woefully incapable of compromise on virtually any level, much less on policy issues that should be as cut and dried and solvable as this.

Now....Let's Talk Economic Development and GDP Growth!

As a cold, calculating financial person, here's the way I see it.  Without regard to personal feelings or human hardship, if our government chooses to let the Dreamers stay in America, it costs us nothing additional.  Everything remains as is.  Steady as she goes.  If we choose to deport them, the direct cost, over time, would be somewhere around $23 Billion.  (The ICE Budget in 2016 was $3.2 Billion and they deported 240,000 people.  Per the AIC (American Immigration Council) in 2012 there were roughly 1.8 Million people who could possibly qualify as Dreamers.....and a total of roughly eleven (11) million "undocumenteds"....probably about half of the 1.8 million actually met the DACA requirements in 2012 ....so we'd have to really ramp up the staff to grab 'em all!  Moreover, since some/many of these people are successful, respected, hard working folks, my guess is that if we tried to throw them out of the country and take their property they might put up a bit of a legal fight, so the deportation cost per-capita could/would increase significantly.  So let's say, due to additional staffing, training inefficiencies and unknown legal costs that the bill to get rid of these folks would come in at an even $30 Billion.

One dirty little secret, that's simply not discussed in polite company, when you think about it, that $30 Billion is actually a boost to US GDP!  (Remember C+I+G+(x-i)?)  If we toss out the Dreamers we're pumping up the "G".  This is obviously part of the administration's master plan for economic growth!  I suppose you could also argue that there are probably some "bad hombres" and potential terrorists in this group, so we, as Americans, if we chose, would be perfectly justified to "round 'em all up" (as well as anyone who looks like 'em) and put them in internment camps like we, and a few other ill-fated regimes did pre/post: WWII.  Remember, not all of the dreamers are Scandinavian and there are more than a few of them that came here from "shit-holes" just trying to survive.  So rather than just look at the numbers, as policy wonks are known to do, as a life long resident of the Shining City on the Hill, I absolutely believe we need to show at least some level of compassion and make the proposed internment camps as nice and comfortable as possible.  Perhaps we can go a step-or-two up from those, although well intentioned (a guy's gotta live within a budget), but sparse, Joe Arpaio "tent city concentration camps"?

Like everything we do in America, our internment camps should be world class and set an example for the global community.  Of course, by building these camps we'd be doing the Dreamers a huge favor (low cost temporary housing) since, after all, they shouldn't have come here in the first place.  Yup....as Americans, we understand that it's always important to do the right thing and treat inferior, minority, non-Scandinavian people somewhere near the way we'd want to be treated if we were in their shoes, which, fortunately for us, would never happen.

In addition, even though, under the US Code, we aren't required to do so for non-US citizens, I also propose that we provide free legal assistance (adding even more government spending to GDP) for the Dreamers.  After all, we gave real terrorists at Gitmo free legal help, so it's the least we can do for the Dreamers.

So when we add the additional legal cost and the cost to build some really nice, world class internment camps, we can probably make the number $40 Billion to dump the Dreamers.....That's right, we're creating GDP and economic growth at every corner!  With this type of guaranteed GDP growth on the table, why in the world would anyone embrace those silly "path to citizenship" proposals?

Now, of course you could also argue that these potential near-criminals are actually stealing US Jobs, enrollment slots at our universities, government resources and hospital beds.  Yes, that could be true.  Whenever I see a "help wanted" sign for a minimum wage job with horrible, unsafe working conditions there is always a long line of middle aged well-dressed Scandinavian-looking people clamoring to work the fields, wash dishes and haul shingles and rough lumber up and down ladders in the hot sun. These wonderful jobs are clearly at risk of being ripped away from rightful hands of American workers if we allow the Dreamers to remain.

Of course, the next logical step, once we get these Dreamers out of our country, is to finally BUILD THAT WALL!   We certainly don't want the Dreamers coming back! This should absolutely be part of the negotiations through February 8th.  I can't think of a better use of tax dollars than to spend $30 Billion on a 20 ft. wall (that can be breached with a 25 ft. ladder) designed to keep frightened, starving Mexican people and other bad hombres from fleeing the gunfire in Juarez and Nogales, marching fifty miles through a sweltering desert in hopes of someday fulfilling their American dream by picking American strawberries, cutting American lawns, washing American dishes and occasionally selling American opioids (McKesson, Cardinal, et. al.) to quasi-law-abiding Caucasian Americans.  These jobs, after all, are the god-given birthright of illegal Scandinavians.

Of course, if the "wall" works as it's proposed, my understanding is that the Canadians are considering a similar program.  They're simply using the American program as a test case.  Canadians are fiscally responsible folks. They just want to see how it goes before they pony up the funds.

Moreover, the proposed, but toothless effort to fund ICE enforcement in a full frontal assault on American businesses who've been chronically breaking immigration laws, and actually apply the stiff employer penalties ($10,000+ per violation) that have been on the books for years, would be absolutely unnecessary once we have that wall built!  Employers could continue to openly hire whoever they want, with no record keeping, pay their employees in cash under the table and beat the snot out of them without repercussion if the illegal employees do something against company policy, just like they do now.....but they can do it much more efficiently with much less paperwork and no fear of government intervention with the free market flow of illegal labor!  That is, after all, what deregulation is all about....

If, god forbid, we chose to enforce these laws and slap big fines on politically connected employers, that action would absolutely destroy any incentive for the Dreamers to come/stay here.  Perhaps, they'd all go "back to where they came from"....then where would we be?  We'd have crops rotting in the fields. Slaughter houses would be idled.  Cow's udders would be exploding in the barns because there would be no cheap illegal labor available to milk them!  There would be no need to hand out big fat government contracts to build a gigantic wall and hire more border security.  Even though the "fleeing the Juarez and Nogales gunfire" incentive would still exist, that fifty mile death march in a sweltering desert would become much less attractive for the fleeing Mexican people if there were no American job waiting for them at the end of the trail.  Perhaps they might consider staying in Mexico and heading south, into the mountains for safety?  Perhaps reducing the size of the massive herd that's crossing now might make it a little easier to identify and pick off the bad hombres?  It's hard to say, but the laws are already on the books and presumably there for a reason.

In fact, my understanding is that larger Southern California, Arizona, New Mexico and Texas employers, treat the ability to survive a harrowing desert crossing, and evade ICE as a quasi management training program.  The ingenuity, perseverance, hard work, austerity and creativity required to survive as an undocumented alien in America are qualities that every employer is looking for.  No wonder the demand for this labor class is at an all time high.  ICE enforcement versus cheap labor is indeed the premier economic trade off of the day.   

That's right, there is also unfortunately an economic downside to every public policy.  With increased ICE enforcement and the absence of cheap "imported" labor the price of strawberries, lettuce, dairy products, new construction and lawn care would double, and many of my favorite restaurants would go under.  But that's the price we'll have to pay for a secure border.  Yup.....I, for one, am really glad our leadership understands these difficult to grasp concepts.

Even MORE Economic Growth Within Easy Reach....

But wait, there's more! We're just scratching the surface on generating huge gobs of additional GDP. It's just come to my attention that more than half of the potential Dreamers are actually unarmed! That's right, our government has systematically denied them their Second Amendment rights. We must put an end to this injustice NOW! If you've had a chance to visit Arizona, home to many of the Dreamers, and you've personally witnessed the running gun battles on the mean streets of Tuscon, Phoenix and Scottsdale (maybe not so much Scottsdale...), as I have (from a distance), you'd know that some of the Dreamers are woefully outgunned.

To that end I've proposed, in a strongly worded letter to my Ohio Senators, Messrs. Brown and Portman, that we take immediate action to fund firearms subsidies for the Dreamers. In Phoenix, like Kabul and Aleppo, we have to level the playing field. If we don't provide the necessary firepower for the Dreamers to defend themselves it won't be long before they start getting pushed around by the more heavily armed and treacherous Scandinavian-looking Americans. I am, of course talking about the long overdue, Federal Assault Rifle Training Education & Distribution program, that's been stuck in committee for decades.

In order to really get the biggest "bang" for our GDP buck (so to speak) we need to extend this program, not only to the Dreamers, but to every, law abiding, God-fearing American. Right now, roughly 2/3rds of all Americans DON'T OWN A GUN!. ...How can this be? I grew up in Wisconsin. My Dad gave me a shotgun when I graduated from grade school. It was a right of passage. The wealthiest country in the world and most of our citizens don't have semi-automatic weapons? THIS MUST CHANGE NOW! If we fully fund this long delayed program we can be well on our way to universal gun ownership.

Here's the GDP math.....

  • A new AR15 assault rifle would cost our government roughly $1,500 a piece (serial number "optional" models are slightly more), with ammo and additional add-ons (bump stocks, laser sites, etc.) we can add another $1,000 to the purchase price. So $2,500 x roughly 210 million brand new gun owners would generate $525 Billion in new GDP! 
  • Since there are roughly 35,000 gun deaths in America every year (2/3rds of which are suicides) (CDC Stats - pg 87) we can also expect a big GDP boost from funeral services associated with gun violence. Like, our airline industry executives, our legislators must wise up. (Airplanes don't kill people....pilots kill people....which is precisely why US Commercial Air carriers are moving away from those costly pilot training programs and background checks. They've seen the light! Statistics have shown that it's much better to just let passengers storm the cockpit and take matters into their own hands if they have a problem with what the pilot is doing... ) We, and America's gun lobby, must take full advantage of the opportunity before us. By providing the Dreamers and another 210 million currently unarmed Americans with assault weapons, we'll generate additional GDP of $1 Billion associated with Funeral Services. (70,000 additional gun deaths x $15,000 per funeral = $1 Billion) 
  • Increased Emergency Room services associated with the dead and wounded would also generate significant GDP, calculated roughly as follows. Since about 2/3rds of America's gunshot victims survive, when we extrapolate, increased GDP due to ramped up ER Services would be calculated as: 70,000 additional deaths....since they still get an ambulance ride to the emergency room and a couple of attempts at life support.....plus the additional 140,000 survivors, multiplied by the average cost of a critical care ER visit of $20,000 is (210,000 visits x $20,000 = $4.2 Billion.....a veritable bonanza of GDP! That's tens of thousands of new, high-paying medical jobs!
  • The 140,000 GSS (Gun Shot Survivors) would also need rehabilitation and home health care for a reasonable time, so let's say, just as a SWAG, 140,000 victims x $3,000/month x 6 months = $2.5 Billion in additional GDP.  More health care jobs! 
All in all, if my math is even close, the Federal Assault Rifle Training Education & Distribution program should generate $532.7 BILLION in ADDITIONAL GDP! Now we're talking!


Summary Of All the Brand New GDP!....$1 Trillion +

Let's summarize.  If we choose to throw the Dreamers out ($40 Billion in new GDP), plus build that wall ($30 Billion in New GDP), and we enforce employer sanctions and fines (a few hundred million in GDP) and fully fund Federal Assault Rifle Training Education & Distribution program($532.7 Billion) we are starting to talk about some real economic growth.

Further adding to GDP (Consumption) Food cost would jump from $1.5 Trillion to about $1.8 Trillion!  That's another $300 Billion of added GDP.  New Housing construction cost would also move up a hundred billion or so due to higher priced Scandinavian-looking labor.  So all in all, we're probably closing in on a TRILLION DOLLARS of additional GDP and another 1.8 million pseudo-Scandinavian-Americans could be put back to work once the Dreamers get the boot....albeit at back-breaking-ball-busting, no-benefits, under the table, below-minimum wage jobs.  But hey.....they're jobs!

All we have to do is systematically round up the Dreamers, secure our borders and fully arm our citizens! That's MAGA BABY!  That's what I'm talking about! Although again, I have to emphasize, skyrocketing food, housing and service industry prices aren't all that attractive to me, but again, MAGA comes with a price tag.  Freedom "don't come cheap".

And you thought the Chinese government was the only global source for unproductive, fake GDP!  Those vacant Chinese apartments, excess capacity and bridges to nowhere can't hold a candle to good old fashioned American know-how and ingenuity.  China might have ghost cities, but we've got Dreamers!  We've got really expensive, rationed health care (the best in the world) that many of us can't find or afford.  We have a wonderful combination of absurdly high-cost college and underfunded primary education.  We have cheap, heavily marketed opiods and military grade weaponry on every street corner! Take that Xi, you ain't even close to the American dream!

The most frightening thing about the plan I describe above, and again I'm just guessing here, is that some people who read this will actually be nodding their heads in full agreement, believing that everything I just wrote is a peachy-keen economic plan which, by coincidence, also happens to reduce government intervention in their lives, gets them a new assault rifle and solves all of our immigration issues in one thundering thud.
 
My Advice to My Fellow Americans

The only thing I can suggest is, like Lincoln's audience at Gettysburg, that we, as a country, take some time to mourn what's happened to us.  After an appropriate period, perhaps by the November(s) of 2018 and 2020, we should conclude our grieving.  Like the poor folks at Gettysburg, we should move forward and make our decisions based solely on our own, very personal life's experience, rather than what other nameless, faceless "friends" are telling us.

Of course, far be it from me to tell anyone what to do.  Since I fully acknowledge that I, as a concerned citizen, with only one vote to my name, have virtually no control over any of this mess.  Again, all we can do is move forward and make the best decisions we can.

Given what's happened in American politics over the last decade or so, what we've heard and seen has been vastly different from what we've "got".  Moreover, the harsh reality is that we need to come to grips with our own fallibility.  We, as an electorate, are simply not capable of figuring out who's lying and who's telling the truth.  We can't tell a good idea from a bad one.  We're unable to identify intelligent, skilled politicians who've been around the block, know what they're doing, think for themselves, aren't shackled to party ideology and are willing to cross the isle to work with members of the other party to actually get something done. We can't tell a potential statesman from a likely charlatan.  We think we can, but we can't.

Since, apparently, no one is part of the solution, by default, everyone is part of the problem.  Here's the list.  Twenty six (26) of our 100 Senators have been on the job for more than 15 years.  They've methodically governed over this disease while it has insidiously festered.  I'd ask, in what other endeavor, save government service, could someone measure their entire career's success, not by what they've accomplished, but by their ability to thwart the accomplishments of others?  Leahy (43 years), Hatch (41 years), Grassley (37 years), McConnell (33 years), Feinstein (25 years), Murray (25 years), Durbin (21 years), etc. etc. etc.  I'm sure that they are all, in their own way, wonderful, patriotic people, fiercely loyal to their party.  Their easily manipulated constituents, I'm sure, love them. Unfortunately, we don't need any more loyal, lovable patriots in government.  We need public servants who can work together effectively to solve problems.

It's becoming clearer by the day that we might never be able to drain the swamp.  Through some sort of political magic, far too many of our public servant Senators somehow manage to accumulate enormous wealth in a few short years while collecting their comparatively minuscule $174,000/yr. salary.  I wonder how they do it?   Although the swamp will undoubtedly remain full, we can certainly make an effort to replace the big old 'gators on a regular basis.  Since these folks would never agree to term limits, it's up to us, the bumbling electorate to take charge.  Like a legislative yard sale.... everything and everyone must go.

That said, over the next few elections, without regard to party affiliation, for any federal office, I plan on naively voting for anyone who does not have the word "incumbent" associated with their name until things start to improve.  I've come to the point where I don't care who's in office, as long as it's "somebody else".

Finally, to re-coin a relatively famous phrase from a big-ly popular reality TV show, directed toward our current beltway leadership:

"You're Fired!"

Additional Reading

Who are the Dreamers?
https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/research/who-and-where-dreamers-are-revised-estimates

Deportation Costs
http://money.cnn.com/2017/04/13/news/economy/deportation-costs-undocumented-immigrant/index.html
   
PS: It doesn't matter if any of the sources or figures I've cited above are accurate.  Now that it's all on the Internet it can be freely quoted as yet another version of the "truth".